What Tyler Perry says about Dark-skinned brothas

Posted: October 10, 2012 by In These Eyes in Racial Issues, Uncategorized

Though I’ve been ranting and raging for years about this guy, I’m going to try to keep this under 1,00o words. I swear.

One thing I can never despise — no matter the circumstance — is a Black man who came from nothing to make something of himself. Tyler Perry, a man whose childhood was  Survived unbearable tragedy and became one of the most successful Black men in Hollywood. It’s no surprise that his net worth is around $350 million, considering his vast body of work includes the award-winning “Precious,” TBS’s “House of Pain” and, most notably, a series of plays and movies starring himself as everyone’s favorite wise-yet-dangerous Black grandmother: “Madea.”

But there’s something very wrong with Tyler Perry’s work. Something very damaging — something, that’s just as dangerous and perpetuating to image culture as Sambo and Aunt Jemima were in the 20th century. Behind a glowing mask of Christian values and woman-empowerment, Tyler Perry’s work attacks with subtle, damning perspectives on Black men — but more specifically — dark-skinned Black men.

‘Dark-skinned Black men are abusive — just like my daddy’

Tyler Perry’s experience with an abusive father are well-documented. According to CNN, Perry’s father locked him in a room and whipped him with a vacuum cord until “the skin was coming off his back,” and constantly told him he was nothing. Perry’s father was the bane of his existence: destroying his household, terrorizing his mother, ruining everything. Though I was unable to find images of Emmit Perry sr., I wonder if his dad is dark-skinned, and if all of Perry’s bad male characters are based on him?  If you look at any of his movies, it would make a hell-of-a-lot of sense.

But in the words of “Reading Rainbow’s: “You don’t have to take my word for it.”


Film: ““

Synopsis: A woman is married a wealthy lawyer who suddenly decides to leave her for his white mistress (the greatest sin in a Black marriage). She is eventually remarried to the U-Haul driver who helped her move out of her place.

Bad Black man’s color (her husband): .

Man who saves her from the abusive relationship (her U-Haul-driver-turned-lover): .

Ok, ok. Maybe that’s just a coincidence. Let’s go to the next one.

Film:  ““

Synopsis: A tale about a woman who announces her engagement to a man, but tells her family that he is physically abusive to her. She’s rescued by a humble bus driver.

Bad Black man’s color (her abusive fiancee):

Man who saves her from the abusive relationship (her bus-driver-turned-lover):

 … Perhaps it’s just a small casting error? Next one:

Film: ““

Synopsis: A lawyer who is assigned to defend a prostitute in a case, falls in love with her after his wife sabotages her records to get her put in prison

Bad Black man (the lawyer): 

Sidenote: he’s technically the protagonist, but leaving your wife for a prostitute makes you bad, in my books

Cheated on wife:

It doesn’t stop

Film: “I Can Do Bad All By Myself”

Synopsis: An alcoholic woman who is involved with an abusive relationship with a married man, is given the responsibility of taking care of her niece and nephew. A Columbian immigrant from her church moves in and saves her from her abusive relationship

Bad Black man (her boyfriend):

Man who saves her from her abusive relationship:


The case is clear: Almost every relationship-killing, abusive male in his movies is a dark-skinned Black man. Every person who comes to save the damsel in distress is a light-skinned Black man (except for the one case where the antagonist wasn’t quite as dark, then they brought in a Columbian to save the day). If you think this is a coincidence, you’re being naive.

The dark men are slapping their wives, leaving them for white women and prostitutes, and even attempting to rape their nieces. They’re primitive — bestial, even — and don’t see how wonderful the women are that they’re with. Just like Tyler Perry’s father.

We’re supposed to hate them. Be disgusted with them. Cheer on as they get hit in the face with hot grits. Grin as they are shot and paralyzed. Feel relieved when their lighter-skinned counterparts sneak in and save the day. And we’re never given a great view of what a dark-skinned Black man is like. Only that we should run from them and seek a lighter man.

Because the lighter, The righter.

I can’t even begin to explain the damage this does to Black men. Don’t we have enough issues? According to “Young Black Americans and the Criminal Justice System: Five Years Later” “One in three Black men between the ages of 20 and 29 years old is under correctional supervision or control.” According to the  Schott Foundation for Public Education, ”Only 41% of Black men graduate from high school in the United States.” We are poorly educated, are targeted and oppressed by the justice system, and have no positive male figures in our lives (According to Reuters, 56 percent of Black children lived in single-parent households).

Do we really need Tyler Perry to portray dark-skinned Blacks as uncivilized beasts? Do we really need Tyler Perry to attack Black men as Black women’s problems, as opposed to people who, just like him, experienced a lot and needed help? When Black people choose to display black people like dirt, it validates the very stereotypes and prejudices we overcame to get to where we are. Which isn’t even that far.

Perry is a traumatized man, no question. But his trauma is negatively contributing to the racial trauma of the nation and giving respectable Black men, like myself, more barriers to breakdown and more reasons to not be trusted.

So for the sake of everything Black in the world, somebody get this man a counselor — or get him the hell away from screenwriting.

  1. Sharice Christina says:

    Idris Elba was good… But on a real tip, I can see how his repertoire can be perceived negatively in that respect. One thing I’m passionate about is how our people throw opportunities away using our ancestors as a crutch. What we have endured as a people are stepping stones on the way to success. I believe he inspires/attracts the attention of our people by the only way probable to get a message through to the majority; laughing at ourselves. He beginning to work more mainstream where he is able to avoid a lot of the ignorance it takes to make our people crack a smile, listen to a song, throw it up in the club. It’s sad it takes all that just get a moral or biblical message across. I do believe every one of his piece’s are a partial reflection of himself and his experiences but all of our works are. Same for you. Personal opinion and perception comes out with your real self. Should views on the world be censored? Because he is able to reach an almost impenetrable demographic on a mass scale it is unfortunate that the things endured may cast additional negative stigma on our people it’s his life. They’re plenty of other role models black men have but they’re not respected in their capacity. It’s not his fault our people are visiting hell on ourselves, he just reflects his perception. You’ll be affecting the masses yourself, you’ll just be conscious enough to direct your influence in a positive light.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s